Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Buffalo Shrimp Pizza
Shrimp Caesar Salad Pizza
Stuffed Round Pie Pizza
Cheesesteak Pizza
About
Garden City Pizza and Catering
Welcome to Garden City Pizza and Catering, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Garden City, NY. With its vibrant menu that spans the best of Italian cuisine, this eatery is renowned for its delectable pizzas, fresh salads, and mouthwatering calzones. If you’re on the hunt for a local spot that brings a taste of Italy with a touch of American flair, then look no further!
Located at 670 Franklin Ave, Garden City Pizza and Catering brings together a warm, casual atmosphere perfect for families, friends, or a quick bite during your lunch break. Whether you prefer dining in, taking out, or enjoying the convenience of delivery, they cater to your needs while maintaining a congenial vibe infused with the aroma of freshly baked pizza.
One of the standout features of Garden City Pizza is its generous portion sizes that make it a value-driven choice. Customers rave about the massive slices—with prices ranging from just $6 to $7. Mayuka K. enthusiastically shares, "The pizzas are absolutely delicious... both were fantastic," while indulging in various flavors shared among family. It’s this reinforcing sense of community and sharing that defines the Garden City Pizza experience.
Among the highlights, the Barbeque Chicken Slice captivates with its savory toppings and crispy crust, offering a delightful blend of tender chicken and tangy BBQ sauce. Another local favorite is the Broccoli Rabe with Sundried Tomatoes Slice, which showcases a perfect balance of earthy vegetables and rich flavors.
- The Chicken Club Panini is a must-try, bringing together grilled chicken, crispy bacon, and fresh greens that creates a medley of flavors delightful for any meal of the day.
- Don’t miss out on their Garlic Knots, soft and chewy rolls kneaded with care and brushed with garlic-infused butter, perfect as a side or a snack.
- For those with dietary restrictions, Garden City Pizza offers an impressive range of vegan options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a meal that suits their lifestyle.
What sets Garden City Pizza apart is not just the food but also its friendly, welcoming staff. Customers like Jakob L. highlight the extraordinary service provided by team members who ensure your experience is memorable, making it not just about great food but also about warm hospitality. With a great ambiance suitable for kids, outdoor seating, and amenities like Wi-Fi and TV for those relaxed moments, it truly caters to a variety of dining preferences.
Garden City Pizza and Catering is not just a pizzeria; it’s a local staple that fosters community. Whether you're there to grab a quick lunch, have a family dinner, or cater an event like mentioned by customer Andrew M., it's clear that this establishment knows how to deliver quality food with a side of exceptional service.
If you’re in the Garden City area, make sure to stop by or call them at (516) 294-2929 for a slice of happiness. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ This pizza place is definitely one of my favorites! The pizzas are absolutely delicious, and at just $6-$7 per slice, it's an amazing deal considering how HUGE the slices are! I recently tried their chicken and mushroom pizza along with the penne pizza, and both were fantastic. I love to share with my family since the portions are so generous, plus it gives me a chance to try a variety of flavors. If you're a fan of premium, mouth-watering pizzas, this place will quickly become your go-to spot! Highly recommend it! ”
“ Slice City in Garden City - My New Weekly Spot! I walked into Slice City on a whim on my way to work, and I'm so glad I did. From the moment I arrived, the team made me feel welcome--especially Eric, who went above and beyond with his friendliness and great recommendations. He made sure I had everything I needed, and his kindness truly set the tone for my visit. Now, the pizza itself? Absolutely phenomenal! I tried the Chicken Bake Slice, the Ya Mon Slice, and the Forger Slice--each one was unique and packed with incredible flavor. The Chicken Bake Slice was perfectly savory and cheesy, with a comforting blend of flavors that hit all the right notes without a hint of spice. The Ya Mon Slice was a tropical delight with jerk chicken, charred pineapple, and sweet plantains, making every bite feel like a mini getaway. And the Forger Slice was a savory, earthy masterpiece topped with the freshest ingredients. On top of all that, the prices were extremely reasonable, especially considering the generous slice sizes. You're getting top-notch quality and flavor without breaking the bank. Slice City just earned themselves a new weekly customer, and I can't wait to explore more of the menu. Huge thanks to Eric and the team for making my morning and pizza experience unforgettable! ”
“ We had this catered to Nunley's for our daughter's birthday and everything was outstanding. Not only was the pizza for the kids excellent, but the sandwich platters for the adults were very delicious. Keep up the great work! ”
“ Garden City Pizza is my weekly go to! I love their house and caesar salads with grilled chicken. They are more than just your traditional pizzeria. GCP cooks with clean and fresh ingredients. After a meal, you feel light not like some other pizza spots that leave you feeling light. I wish they were open on Sundays! ”
“ Had this place for the first time and I'd highly recommend! The fried buffalo bites were amazing, and the salad had an amazing balsamic glaze! Definitely going back! ”
“ The food is super, the owner , staff great. Why try the rest when you can try the best ”
“ This pizzeria has been a part of the Garden City community for many years. They offer a wide variety of different slices and everything here is very fresh. The sauce is on the sweeter side but is good. Service here is quite fast and they offer tables outside to eat at when it's nice outside. I've come here for many years and will continue to do so. It's a solid pizzeria. ”
“ Traveler's Q had the opportunity to partner with Garden City Pizza and Catering for a recent event, and we couldn't be happier with the outcome. We faced a challenge - a large order, same day, with unique dietary requirements. But guess what? They stepped up to the plate and delivered beyond our expectations. Let's talk about flexibility. We needed vegan and gluten-free options, and they didn't bat an eyelid. The team at Garden City Pizza and Catering whipped up a variety of delicious dishes that catered to every guest's needs. Worried about the freshness of your food? Don't be. Our order arrived warm, right on time, proving that prompt delivery and maintaining quality are not mutually exclusive for this team. They also brought creativity to the table. When it came to deciding what would work best for our party, they provided fantastic suggestions that hit the mark. It was clear they weren't just thinking about filling bellies but also about enhancing the overall experience. In a nutshell? Garden City Pizza and Catering proved themselves to be a reliable, innovative, and high-quality choice for our catering needs. If you're in Garden City, NY, and need a caterer who can deliver (in every sense of the word), look no further. Rating: ”
“ First time ordering and it was delicious. We typically order from another pizzeria for my workplace but today I decided to try something new. I looked up close by pizzerias and GCP was up on the list with 4 stars. I decided to go with them. I ordered 2 large regular pies, Chicken & Tomatoes Pie and The Vegetable with Cheese pie. It wasn't your regular pie either it was a vegetable medley pie with broccoli, zucchini, squash and broccoli. ”
